At the recent countering Financial Crime conference, a panel was held which covered the use of country lists. The panel sparked much debate over the best way to implement the lists effectively. The following is a quick guide on how operators can use Country Lists effectively.
The Isle of Man Department of Home Affairs publishes three lists.
Where list A jurisdictions require an automatic response, Lists B and C require a holistic assessment. The list result should therefore inform, rather than replace, the operators wider risk assessment. For gambling-sector compliance professionals and supervisors, the challenge is to apply country information consistently while keeping the assessment proportionate, evidence-based and capable of adapting as risks change.
Grey-listing is a risk indicator and should trigger further consideration, but the firm still needs to assess the specific relationship, activity and wider risk profile in relation to their business. The FATF grey list contains jurisdictions where strategic deficiencies have been identified, but which have made a high-level political commitment to work with FATF or regional body to address those deficiencies within agreed timeframes. It signals that the jurisdiction deserves closer consideration – However, a grey list status does not automatically indicate that every person, entity or transaction connected to that jurisdiction is automatically to also be deemed high risk in the same way.
For the gambling sector, a genuine risk-based approach requires the operator to understand why the jurisdiction is relevant and how it connects to the customer, business model or wider structure.
Jurisdictional risk is not limited to where the customer is resident or located. Operators need to consider the wider structure:
It is also important to recognise that criminal methodologies are adaptive. Where particular routes, jurisdictions, payment methods or structures attract focus from supervisors, LEAs or industry, criminals will change tactics and move activity elsewhere. A strong approach would show how the country list position has been considered alongside the firm’s own exposure and other relevant information. The National Risk Assessment (NRA) and NRAS will also provide important context, but the outcome must still reflect the specific facts of the business relationship.
This point is particularly relevant to online gambling because it is a remote, international sector. The use of cross-border customer relationships, international corporate structures, third-party providers, payment intermediaries and digital onboarding can create risk indicators that are not captured by a country list alone.
It is therefore important to consider other sources such as the NRA and NRAS, and to stay abreast of international and geopolitical developments.
During an onsite inspection, supervisors expect to see a documented and clear path from the country-list information to the final decision. That path should show what was identified, what other evidence was considered, why the controls were proportionate and when the assessment will be reviewed.
Supervisors are often interested in whether firms understand why their structures and relationships operate as they do. For example:
It is not only about whether a connection exists, but whether the connection creates a risk that is material in the circumstances and whether the risk can be understood and managed through proportionate controls.
Best practice would be to show:
Country lists have value, but only when applied proportionately and appropriately. The lists should not be used in isolation or treated as a shortcut to automatic de-risking.
The right response is enhanced understanding and proportionate mitigation, not automatic de-risking - unless the firm cannot understand or manage the risk. The lists are not a substitute for understanding the unique ML/TF/PF risk presented by a customer, relationship, service or transaction so ensure a risk-based approach is undertaken and documented.
For more information on the GSC’s AML Code Requirements, view the video series on YouTube, or read the AML/CFT resources on our website.